Email Marketing

12 Qualities to Look For When Choosing an Email Marketing Agency

Here is what can help you decide when choosing an email marketing agency




post cover

It's no secret that email marketing is one of the most cost-effective ways to generate sales for your business. But, if you don't have the time or expertise to successfully create and launch a marketing campaign, it may be worth looking into hiring an email marketing agency. The right email marketing company will strategize with you to meet your company's goals, make your life easier, and increase bottom-line growth.

So how do you find these much-needed agencies? Here are the top 12 qualities you should look for when choosing the right email marketing agency for your needs:

Great reputation 

One of the best ways to learn about an email marketing agency is through reputation and reviews. When you are considering an email marketing agency, it’s important to look at the company’s website and see what customers have to say about the services they provide. You should also check out third-party review sites like Glassdoor or YELP and read customer reviews that were left within the last 12 months. Look for reviewers who are specific in their praise or criticism, as well as those who detail exactly how they were helped by the firm.

Finally, make sure that you read reviews written by people whose businesses are similar to yours! The more specific a review is, the better chance it has of being helpful – after all, if someone else went through a process similar enough to yours then maybe their experience will be similar enough too!

Profitable and custom strategies 

As your business grows, you’re going to need help. This is true whether you’re just starting out or have been in business for decades. As your company continues to grow, it will be necessary for you to hire more people and outsource tasks in order to keep up with demand.

One of the most important things a marketing agency can do is help guide its clients as they scale their businesses. They should be able to tell you what kinds of strategies work best when scaling your growth and how they can be used effectively at every stage of growth.

Premium customer service

The best way to be sure that your concerns are being handled is to look for an email marketing agency that offers premium customer service. This means:

  • 24/7 availability. You should be able to get in touch with a representative at any time of day, as long as you’re willing to pay extra for it.

  • Friendly and responsive agents who will go out of their way to make sure they understand your needs before answering questions or solving problems, even if it takes multiple emails back-and-forth between the two parties involved.

  • An available team of multilingual individuals who can help you communicate with customers from all over the world in their native languages.

  • Customer support representatives who are available on different platforms (ex: Live Chat vs Email) so that clients can reach out at their convenience instead of having one main point of contact (i.e., via phone).

Strong portfolio

Another important thing you should look for in an agency is a portfolio. Think of this like a resume or cover letter: if it’s not impressive, you won't be impressed. The best way to judge an email marketing agency based on its portfolio is by looking at the projects they have done in the past, the variety of them, and whether they have been able to adapt to their client's needs throughout those projects. You should also make sure that each project has results attached to it so that you can see how effective the company has been in producing results for customers.

You might be wondering why we're talking about portfolios when we haven't even mentioned results yet (you'll get there!). It's because when you look at an agency's portfolio, you will start getting a feel for what kind of work they do and how good they are at doing it. Generally speaking—and this goes for any industry—the best agencies know what type of work needs to be done before anyone else does because they spend so much time researching trends and identifying problems within their industry before going after clients who need help solving those problems

There are no hidden fees 

When you’re looking for an email marketing agency, there are 2 things to watch out for:

  • Hidden fees – Some companies will charge extra fees on top of the agreed-upon cost. This can be confusing and frustrating if you’re not sure what they’re charging extra for.

  • Reasonable charges – Make sure that the price quoted is reasonable and fits your budget. If you are not sure, ask questions about what services are included in their offerings and how much those services cost separately or together. You may even want to request a breakdown of their charges so that you have an idea of what all goes into running your email marketing campaigns (and how much each individual service costs).

Data Security

Data security is a top priority for any agency. Your data is valuable and should be taken care of with the utmost caution. The best way to ensure your data’s safety is by making sure that the agency you choose has implemented a strong data security policy.

You want to make sure they have a well-written and reviewed document that outlines their policies on how they keep your information safe, who can access it, how long it will be stored and what happens when someone leaves the company or retires.

Make sure your agency has this policy in place and review it regularly (at least once a year) so you know exactly what’s going on with how they handle your information.

Attention to Detail

Attention to detail is a must. It’s important that the agency you choose is able to handle multiple projects at once and meet deadlines, but it’s also vital that they listen closely and communicate clearly. You need someone who can manage your expectations, especially when it comes to their ability to hit deadlines. After all, if there are no consequences for missing an appointment or deadline, then why would they care? A good email marketing agency will take pride in their work and put forth effort towards making sure everything goes smoothly from start to finish—and beyond!

Customized Approach

When you're looking for an email marketing provider, it's important to find one that will work with you on a customized basis. The best companies will take the time to listen to your needs and understand your business. They'll then be able to offer a solution that fits seamlessly into your workflow, making it easy for everyone involved in the process.

Analytics and Reporting

Analytics and reporting are important for tracking results. The agency should provide you with data that gives you insight into how your campaigns have performed, including:

  • Email open rates

  • Click-through rates

  • Bounce rate (how many people it took to leave your site after reading the email)

  • Unsubscribe rate (how many people unsubscribed from your list)

This information will help you determine if the campaign was successful or not and if there are any changes that need to be made for future campaigns. Make sure this data is accessible to both the agency and yourself so that you can use it to improve campaigns as needed.

Transparent Services and Pricing

The first thing you should look for in an email marketing agency is transparency. You need to know exactly what you’re paying for and what the results will be before you sign on with them.

You should know exactly how much your campaign will cost (and how much it will cost if additional work is needed). One way that some agencies deceive customers is by charging “per email sent” or “per thousand emails sent”, but this can lead to sticker shock when they send millions of emails over the course of the project.

Also, make sure the agency isn’t promising results that are too good to be true! If all goes well, your campaign will perform better than expected; however, there may be times when things don't go as planned and it's important not only that you're clear on what these scenarios might look like ahead of time but also how they would affect pricing (if at all)

Content Strategy

Content strategy is a vital part of your email marketing campaign, but it can be easy to overlook. Email readers are more likely to click on emails that contain relevant content. That's why it's important for you to ensure that your content matches the needs of your target audience.

A good content strategy will help you categorize and organize all of your different types of emails so that you can easily create new ones in the future. If you're using an agency, they should be able to assist with this process as well!

Dedication to Your Success, Not Your Dollar

When you choose an email marketing agency, it’s important to keep in mind that they are not just there for you for the money. There are tons of companies out there that will take your money and then do nothing more than sending emails with little care or effort behind them. Don’t settle for this!

You want to make sure that the company cares about your success as much as they do their own. They should have a vested interest in seeing your business grow and thrive because it means more work for them down the road. And who wouldn’t want to work with someone who is invested in their success?

We hope you feel more empowered to choose the right email marketing agency for your business. While there are many available options, it's important that you find a company that can provide cost-effective and lasting results. Remember, this is an investment in your future and should be taken seriously! If you do your homework beforehand, then success will follow soon after.

An image to showcase the email warmup feature

Reach more customers with your cold emails

Table of Contents

    In a nutshell

    Attention to detail is important when choosing an email marketing agency because small mistakes can impact the success of an email campaign and damage a company's reputation.
    Businesses might hire an email marketing agency to save time and resources, increase email deliverability and engagement, and access expertise and advanced tools.
    A person can learn about an email marketing agency's reputation by researching online reviews, requesting references, and checking their portfolio and track record.
    A marketing agency should be able to scale their services and adapt to a client's changing needs as their business grows.
    An email marketing agency's portfolio showcases their past work and demonstrates their expertise in different industries and types of campaigns.
    person opening a mailbox

    Subscribe to our Newsletter!

    Digital advice costs money but we send it to
    your inbox for free.

    Time is Money, and We're About to Save You Both!

    Book a quick demo of our email marketing tools and watch as we transform your leads into loyal customers.


    All-in-one email marketing solution that is tailored specifically for your needs.

    +1 307-461-9872

    [email protected]

    Get in touch

    Subscribe to our weekly Newsletter and receive updates via email.

    © 2024 GoCustomer All rights reserved.